Disclosure Tradeoff

The Source Calculus

You are the senior advisor to the BIS Director. Four disclosure postures, each one foreclosing the others. Weigh enforcement signal against source protection in the 72 hours after the alert.

A trackable Chip Security Act server is sitting in a Tehran data center, attesting cleanly through a Singapore-Hong Kong-Dubai diversion chain. The on-chip telemetry worked. The doctrine has not been written. The Director wants your recommendation by close of business across four options: full disclosure, quiet enforcement, run-as-source, or a sequenced hybrid. Pick a posture. Watch the intelligence-value and enforcement-signal scales move against each other. The full scenario lives in The Server That Phoned Home.

Back to the briefing